Choose a motor using torque, speed, duty cycle and cooling conditions rather than a peak efficiency figure alone. Include the inverter and gearbox, and evaluate losses and temperature at the operating points used most often.
Contents
Motor selection has moved from the previous stage of “simply meeting output and rotational speed” to an era in which optimization includes efficiency, torque density, control difficulty, thermal design, material procurement, and even e-Axle integration. Especially for EVs and high-efficiency industrial equipment, the optimal solution varies greatly depending on the application. In this article, we will explain the differences between the main methods and the selection points that are difficult to ignore depending on the application.
Conditions to verify on a motor test bench
| Item | What to check | How to assess it |
|---|---|---|
| Load | Torque, speed and time profile | Separate continuous and short-term ratings |
| Temperature | Coolant, airflow and ambient conditions | Continuous operation after thermal stabilisation |
| Power | Voltage, current and losses | Include inverter efficiency |
Background/market trends
Technical knowledge: Selection of optimal motor by application
When selecting an EV or high-performance electric motor, it is important to consider not only rated output, but also torque response in the low speed range, efficiency over a wide speed range, overload resistance, weight/volume, cost, reliability, and ease of integration with inverters and reducers. In other words, rather than choosing the "most efficient method" across the board, it is necessary to choose the method according to the drive cycle, thermal constraints, packaging constraints, and material constraints (MDPI World Electric Vehicle Journal, April 2022).
Motor comparison table by application
| Technology | Typical efficiency | Torque density | Relative cost | Control complexity | Optimal use |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BLDC | High | High | Medium to slightly high | Medium | Two-wheel EV, small mobility, auxiliary equipment, fans/pumps |
| PMSM | Operating-point dependent | Very high | Moderately high | High | Passenger EV main engine, servo, high response/high efficiency applications |
| SRM | High, with substantial variation between designs | Medium to high | low to medium | High | Industrial machinery, commercial vehicles, and high-temperature/high-reliability applications that emphasize rare earth-free |
| axial flux | Potential for very high efficiency | Very high | High | High | High-performance EV, aviation, and applications with severe axial space constraints |
*The above table is a representative trend organized from published literature and manufacturer's published values. Actual efficiency and density will vary depending on rotation speed, cooling, magnet material, winding, and inverter conditions (MDPI World Electric Vehicle Journal, April 2022; MDPI World Electrification, September 2020; MDPI Energies, September 2025; IEEE/OSTI, March 2023).
Efficiency depends on speed, torque, temperature and inverter operating conditions. Compare efficiency maps at frequently used operating points, rather than peak efficiency alone. Winding fill factors also depend on insulation and manufacturing conditions. For exports, check efficiency requirements for the relevant product category and power range.
SRM's strength is its simple structure, with no windings or magnets in the rotor. It has the advantages of high starting torque, high speed operation, fault tolerance, and is rare earth free, making it a strong candidate for projects where cost and supply stability are important. However, torque ripple and noise are still major issues, and unless the control system and NVH countermeasures are also evaluated, the actual evaluation is likely to be worse than a theoretical comparison (MDPI World Electric Vehicle Journal, April 2022).
When comparing power-density figures, distinguish short-term peak power from continuous power, check the cooling conditions, and establish whether the figure describes a prototype or a production product. A motor that is thin in the axial direction does not necessarily make the complete system smaller once cooling and the gearbox are included.
Efficiency depends on speed, torque, temperature and inverter operating conditions. Compare efficiency maps at frequently used operating points, rather than peak efficiency alone. Winding fill factors also depend on insulation and manufacturing conditions. For exports, check efficiency requirements for the relevant product category and power range.
Furthermore, these days, optimizing the motor alone is not enough. In EV architecture, a configuration that integrates a motor, fixed reduction gear, and differential is considered to be one of the mainstream, and "3-in-1 e-Axle = motor, inverter, and reduction gear integrated in a common housing" is becoming more common in mass-produced products. Valeo defines the 3-in-1 eAxle as a shared package of motor, inverter, and reducer, and promotes space-saving and low-cost. AISIN and JATCO are also promoting 5-in-1 and Xin1 over 3-in-1, and in the future, the emphasis on selection will shift from "which motor" to "which electric drive unit configuration is optimal" (MDPI World Electric Vehicle Journal, April 2022; Valeo, September 2024; AISIN, see publication page).
Efficiency depends on speed, torque, temperature and inverter operating conditions. Compare efficiency maps at frequently used operating points, rather than peak efficiency alone. Winding fill factors also depend on insulation and manufacturing conditions. For exports, check efficiency requirements for the relevant product category and power range.
Summary/Outlook
In terms of practical selection, BLDC is recommended for small mobility and auxiliary equipment, PMSM is recommended for passenger EV main engines and high-efficiency servos, SRM is recommended if rare earth-free, high temperature, and high reliability are important, and Axial Flux is recommended for high-performance applications where axial space is tight. However, as the use of 3-in-1 e-axles continues to advance, the unit of optimization will shift from a single motor to the entire electric drive system, including the inverter, reduction gear, cooling, EMC, and NVH. Motor selection is becoming less about component selection and more about system architecture design.
Technical support information
At LinkT&B, we provide development support that spans power conversion, heat, and control, with a focus on motor drive circuit and inverter design. For details on research and development support, please see Service introduction page, and for individual consultation, please see Contact page.
Related Articles
SiC MOSFETs in 2026: Technology Trends and Selection Criteria
Server Power Supplies: How AI Is Changing Power Design
:Discuss your project
We support circuit design, prototyping and hardware testing. Tell us about the operating conditions and the problem you need to investigate.